They both look like retic's to me. The bottom one looks like a male and they tend to not have as much of a "reticulated" pattern as the females. They should have mostly reticulated looking offspring. Cool frogs! I am still looking for a male.
BTW- the hawaiin's are thought to have come from Toboga (Panama), which is where the reticulated populations originate from.
I have been keeping a 2.1 trio of reticulated auratus for about 4 years. The males are very reticulated, while the female has much wider bands and less reticulated patterning than the males. I do remember reading somewhere that someone claimed in their experience that they do not always produce true reticulated offspring. I have morphed over a hundred froglets from this trio, every single one has been very reticulated. A small auratus, easily my favorite.