Dendroboard banner

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
Banned
Joined
·
503 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I'm getting 2 tincs, a 1.1 thing, and I was worried about 2 urgent things, yeah yeah, dont freakin tell me 2 tincs won't work/breed in a horz 10 g, idc! I know they will be happy. But now to the ISSUES. My biggest one being lighting. When I put my glass cover on, it cuts out ALOT of light. On a scale of 1 to 10, 10 without the lid being on, and 0 being no lights on at all. It's about 6-6.5 with the cover on. I'mm worried because i'm getting broms and worried they would die, and also 8 vines. My SECOND ISSUE is tincs and laying eggs inside the cup of the broms. Why can't I just leave the eggs/tads in them? Why do I have to take them out? Please help. I've never bred darts before and had success, so please help. I really want to raise some tads and sell some to make more money for the root system build I have in mind. Thank you !
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
86 Posts
You earned the wow due to the fact you look past the size issue and straight to secondary issues. When a post is started telling the reader to ignore a major issue it makes it harder for people to want to help. People reply to posts to try and help others be successful and keep healthy frogs, if a poster ignores that advice it limits the help they will receive in the future.
I wish the best for you and your future frogs if you decide to get any.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,464 Posts
Sorry bro you came off really hostile by pretty much rejecting outright something that you assume people are going to tell you. Coming and asking for advice and flat out saying don't give me the advise I DON'T want to hear is rude and confrontational, so understand you're putting people off right from the start. Why would they want to offer advise when you're knowingly rejecting sound advise in the first place.

I've found everyone on this board to be very open and helpful. Sometimes I might not like their advice but I listen to it because their are some really knowledgeable and experienced people here.

It seems you're generally aware of a pevailing consensus that a pair of tincs in that size tank isn't the best idea. Ok fine you're doing it anyway and thats ok. Some have had sucess doing this so stands to reason that you MIGHT too.

Not enought info to TRY to help with your lighting issue. Can you post pictures?

As for your tincs breeding in brom cups. Uhmmmmm wow. Google breeding tinctorius or use the search function on these forums. You'll find your understanding of breeding them is flawed and exactly why you should take the eggs from the parents, especially if you want to successfully breed them to make money for your other project.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
136 Posts
Sorry Johny I was at work that night on my lunch and I didnt have the time to fully post all the thoughts going on in my mind.
Lets see if I can help... BTW yes what everyone said as to my post Wow.... was exactly what i was refering to, anyway on to the helping part.

1. Yes while it may be possible to set up a 10 gal tank for a breeding pair of tincs lets start with the obvious, do you know for a fact that they are a breeding pair or are you going to buy 2 frogs or even froglets IN HOPES of obtaining a breeding pair.
Lets first say you by 2 frogs in hopes they are... you put them in the 10 gal tank and you take off to the store, school (i asume your young enough to still be in school) or work for a few hrs and come back to a dead frog...
Why you will ask, its probably because the tank was so small there was no were to retreat to for the bullied frog, even in a big tank at least there may be a retreat till you rescue.

2. Even the pros here probbly dont use 10gal for tincs. Did you bother to ask them if this was wise?
Me personaly... I feel tincs are way to big for a 10 gal. By the time you set up background with plants and rocks and vines and what ever you put into it there is no way I would ever house tincs in a 10gal. I probably wouldnt even house Thumbs in a 10 gal. but thats me and I am only a novice (started in March but have read Dendroboard and Dartfrogz and Frog Forums EVERY DAY since my start in March) 10 gal in my oppinion is a great QT tank.

3. Lighitng and your top, If you honestly put your top on and its cutting your light by that much I would guess that the material your top is made of is not a good top.
Is it glass? is it Lexan? is it plexiglass? does it have some sort of tint to it?
I whent to the local glass shop and got a 16 7/8 x 14 3/8 and 1/8 thick glass piece cut for 11.00 non tinted non tempered straight up glass.

4. Bromes wont die from lack of light they will not fully color in lack of light.
Vines on the other hand fully depends on the type of vine, but in most cases they just will grow very slowly due to lack of light.

5. As for removing eggs I can not answer that maybe someone will be as nice as I have been and answer your question. I will sugest that it may have something to do with A. succsess rate or B. other frogs eat them. In wich case if you get a breeding pair and not a trio you might not have an issue and can leave them in the brom. AGAIN I am not the guy for this answer.

In closing Johny dont open a post statting flaws to your build and telling people to ignor them in hopes of advice on other issues.

This is an EXPENSIVE HOBBY and should be treated with RESPECT!!!!
If you had 2 children right now and they were kept in a closet do you actualy think they would be happy?
Placing 2 tincs in a 10gal box how do you know they will be happy?
You cant force happiness

Also yes the extra money you might make from selling frogs would be nice this hobby is in no way profitable. By the time you spend on Tank Tank Build materials Frogs Food QT tanks Tadpole growth equipment shipping materials and shipping I doubt you will make enough money to buy a can of GS.

Anyway Johny I hope you read this I hope you think about some of the things we mentioned to you and I hope you learn from it, not just about the frogs but about your self as well.
best of luck to you and your frogs!

Zorloc
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,415 Posts
When did you get a 10 gallon viv? You have been posting pictures of what started as a 10 gallon viv, but with your background and large pond, it is obvious that you have only about 5 gallons of space. So lets be honest here and you can tell us that you are cramming these frogs into a 5 gallon viv and you really don't care what we think about it.
To anyone else, I apologize for my attitude here but op has pretty much set the tone of this post's "attitude".
I guess I take personal offense to an op telling the entire board to shove it, in the very first sentence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RikRok

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,415 Posts
If you had 2 children right now and they were kept in a closet do you actualy think they would be happy?
Zorloc
Half of a closet. You're forgetting about the bathtub you store in there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EvilLost

·
Banned
Joined
·
503 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
When did you get a 10 gallon viv? You have been posting pictures of what started as a 10 gallon viv, but with your background and large pond, it is obvious that you have only about 5 gallons of space. So lets be honest here and you can tell us that you are cramming these frogs into a 5 gallon viv and you really don't care what we think about it.
To anyone else, I apologize for my attitude here but op has pretty much set the tone of this post's "attitude".
I guess I take personal offense to an op telling the entire board to shove it, in the very first sentence.
Eh, I guess you are right. And I do apologize for my attitude. I did make the pond smaller, but it was alot of work, but now I have about 8 gallons of space. If 2 tincs wont work, do you think an imitator would? no? thanks.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
503 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Sorry Johny I was at work that night on my lunch and I didnt have the time to fully post all the thoughts going on in my mind.
Lets see if I can help... BTW yes what everyone said as to my post Wow.... was exactly what i was refering to, anyway on to the helping part.

1. Yes while it may be possible to set up a 10 gal tank for a breeding pair of tincs lets start with the obvious, do you know for a fact that they are a breeding pair or are you going to buy 2 frogs or even froglets IN HOPES of obtaining a breeding pair.
Lets first say you by 2 frogs in hopes they are... you put them in the 10 gal tank and you take off to the store, school (i asume your young enough to still be in school) or work for a few hrs and come back to a dead frog...
Why you will ask, its probably because the tank was so small there was no were to retreat to for the bullied frog, even in a big tank at least there may be a retreat till you rescue.

2. Even the pros here probbly dont use 10gal for tincs. Did you bother to ask them if this was wise?
Me personaly... I feel tincs are way to big for a 10 gal. By the time you set up background with plants and rocks and vines and what ever you put into it there is no way I would ever house tincs in a 10gal. I probably wouldnt even house Thumbs in a 10 gal. but thats me and I am only a novice (started in March but have read Dendroboard and Dartfrogz and Frog Forums EVERY DAY since my start in March) 10 gal in my oppinion is a great QT tank.

3. Lighitng and your top, If you honestly put your top on and its cutting your light by that much I would guess that the material your top is made of is not a good top.
Is it glass? is it Lexan? is it plexiglass? does it have some sort of tint to it?
I whent to the local glass shop and got a 16 7/8 x 14 3/8 and 1/8 thick glass piece cut for 11.00 non tinted non tempered straight up glass.

4. Bromes wont die from lack of light they will not fully color in lack of light.
Vines on the other hand fully depends on the type of vine, but in most cases they just will grow very slowly due to lack of light.

5. As for removing eggs I can not answer that maybe someone will be as nice as I have been and answer your question. I will sugest that it may have something to do with A. succsess rate or B. other frogs eat them. In wich case if you get a breeding pair and not a trio you might not have an issue and can leave them in the brom. AGAIN I am not the guy for this answer.

In closing Johny dont open a post statting flaws to your build and telling people to ignor them in hopes of advice on other issues.

This is an EXPENSIVE HOBBY and should be treated with RESPECT!!!!
If you had 2 children right now and they were kept in a closet do you actualy think they would be happy?
Placing 2 tincs in a 10gal box how do you know they will be happy?
You cant force happiness

Also yes the extra money you might make from selling frogs would be nice this hobby is in no way profitable. By the time you spend on Tank Tank Build materials Frogs Food QT tanks Tadpole growth equipment shipping materials and shipping I doubt you will make enough money to buy a can of GS.

Anyway Johny I hope you read this I hope you think about some of the things we mentioned to you and I hope you learn from it, not just about the frogs but about your self as well.
best of luck to you and your frogs!

Zorloc
I did ask about frogs in my 10g in another thread. People were suggesting luecs, auratus, and tincs. They said luecs don't use the water feature, so that was out right away. So I was left with auratus and tincs. Since I had a background, I thought the tincs would be happy if they could and some space there. So I thought tincs, then I went overboard. I guess I was stupid. I did research after putting this post up about tincs and auatus. People said they could keep 1 auratus easily in a 10 gallon, and some used the waterfall. As with tincs, there wasa lot of debate for them in a 10 gallon, let alone a 10g with awaterfall. If you could put some imput on how you think auratus would do i'd be very happy. Thanks!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,464 Posts
This thread kinda renews my hatred for the WAY to common 10 gallon tank. I really just wish they wouldn't make it or sell it to new hobbiests. It is just too small no matter how you slice it. Yes, someone with time and experience can make it work in many applications, but beginers should IMO, be pushed toward something larger. Volume solves so many problems when you're trying to keep life inside a glass box. Generally speaking the more space you have the better off you will be, especially as a beginer. This goes wether you're housing darts, fish, reptiles, or an invert.

Please pros and people who use 10s don't misconstrue this. I've set up tons of them and they have their place.

Johny. Glad to see you "took your lumps" and appologized.

Given what you have going I think you'ld probably be ok with a couple (2) smaller dendros in there like say the, IMO, underappreciated vittatus or a couple Auratus. I think anyone would be hesitant to suggest imitators and you'ld really want to rethink how your 10 was set up, hint you'ld want to make it a vert for imitators. They're great frogs but you'll do better with them with more experience. Me personally I've taken care of darts on and off for almost 15 years and I'm just now giving them a go. This isn't to say you can't do it. With the right amount of research, patience, setuptime, etc.. you could start with a thumbnail of some sort.

Good luck!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,415 Posts
Eh, I guess you are right. And I do apologize for my attitude. I did make the pond smaller, but it was alot of work, but now I have about 8 gallons of space. If 2 tincs wont work, do you think an imitator would? no? thanks.

No prob Johny. Come by and we'll shake and make up. You can check out my thumbnail vivs. You're not that far from me.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
379 Posts
I've never bred darts before and had success, so please help.
I wonder why you haven't had any success... Thumbnails would be better suited for that kind of viv, but I wouldn't suggest a thumbnail until you get some experience with the larger, beginner frogs. Two tincs would be a great start, but please listen to the rest of the board when they tell you that tank won't be suited for them. They are terrestrial frogs that need plenty of floor space. They like to lay their eggs on petri dishes placed under coco huts. Please do some more research before you go ahead and purchase these frogs.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
379 Posts
No prob Johny. Come by and we'll shake and make up. You can check out my thumbnail vivs. You're not that far from me.
Visit Doug!! He is very knowledgeable and would be a great mentor for anyone getting into the hobby :D
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top